I am Article Layout

Select your investor profile:

This content is only for the selected type of investor.

US presidential vote and investment implications

November 2020

A divided government in the US? Investors can live with that

Political gridlock in the US is not as bad for financial markets as it seems.

The outcome of the US election awaits official confirmation, yet the signs are Democrat Joe Biden will narrowly win the presidency. Meanwhile, the "Blue Wave" financial markets and pollsters envisaged on the eve of the ballot has not materialised: the Democrats may have retained control of House of Representatives but look to have failed in their bid to secure a majority in the Senate.

All this, and the fact that President Donald Trump has a mountain to climb to put up a credible legal challenge to the vote, inform our investment thinking. 

It was clear from the moment the final vote was cast that this election would turn out to be a much tighter contest than the vast majority of pollsters had predicted. It is testimony to how divided the nation has become. Biden’s thin winning margin – of around 2 per cent of the popular vote - and the Republicans’ strong showing translate into what we think is a very weak mandate for a leftward shift in economic policy.

Even if some high-ranking Republican politicians have adopted a more conciliatory tone in recent days (Senate majority leader Mitch McConnell has been particularly emollient) the adversarial tendencies of Trumpism might outlive the Trump presidency.

This has implications both in the short and long run. Near term, it raises the risk of a messy legal skirmish over the results. But more importantly over the long run, it means many of Biden’s most ambitious policies could founder.

Fig. 1 - Asset allocation grid
Asset allocation grid

Source: Pictet Asset Management. Data as of 05.11.2020.

For one thing, his tax and spending policies are likely to be cut down to size. While a new fiscal package should still be approved by the end of the year – along the lines of a compromise that was sketched out in negotiations before the election – it will be a more modest proposal.

We expect additional measures to amount to around USD1.5 trillion, significantly short of the USD2.2 trillion we had envisaged in the event of a Democratic clean sweep. All of which means the US Federal Reserve may find itself having to loosen the monetary reins even further if Covid-19 infection rates continue to rise.

Biden will inevitably have to water down his plans for tax hikes, too. His proposal to increase the statutory corporation tax rate from 21 per cent to 28 per cent, for instance, could be shelved altogether. This will provide a welcome boost for US corporate profits. Biden’s plan would have cut some 10 per cent from S&P 500 earnings per share by 2020, according to our calculations.

Proposals for increased regulatory oversight of the energy industry are also likely to meet stiff resistance from a Republican-controlled Senate.

A re-set of US's international relations, battle with Covid

Biden will probably have an easier time when it comes to re-setting the US’s international relations. Although we don’t expect him to make significant changes to trade policy, he is sure to adopt a more multi-lateral approach. Expect to see a normalisation of the US’s dealings with international institutions and a less confrontational attitude towards China.

Another distinguishing feature of a Biden administration could be its handling of Covid-19. Generally speaking, Democrats are in favour of more restrictive measures to contain the virus – this could have economic consequences even if the responsibility for the introduction and oversight of such policies ultimately rest with states and local governments. 

Interestingly, there are some matters upon which both parties agree and could, over time, develop a bi-partisan approach.

The most important of these is infrastructure spending. We expect to see a significant increase in infrastructure investment over the next few years – even if the amount likely to be agreed for green projects may be lower than the Democrats would have wanted. Environmental and clean energy technology is a key pillar of Biden's USD2 trillion infrastructure investment programme.

Policymaking should become less erratic with Biden in the White House, which could reduce stocks' risk premium over time.

A divided government has various implications for investors. 

We believe a Biden win with a split Congress is perhaps the best outcome for riskier asset classes in the medium term. Trump’s corporate tax cuts will stay in place while fiscal stimulus should turn out to be sufficient, not excessive. What is more, policymaking should become less erratic with Biden in the White House, which could reduce stocks' risk premium over time.

The markets have already reacted positively to the election outcome – with strong gains in equities and a decline in bond yields – the latter providing a major boost for growth stocks. A Biden administration with a more conventional approach to international relations should also provide a boost to emerging market assets, in which we retain an overweight position.

That said, riskier assets continue to trade in a range that has largely held since September and there is nothing to suggest that the threat posed by Covid-19 has dissipated. So even if it appears that stocks are in a bull market and are likely to build on their gains next year, particularly in cyclical sectors, risks remain in the short term. Which means we cannot justify taking a more bullish stance.